Have you considered getting into Real Estate?
A beautiful shot of Richmond, Virginia skyline with a cloudy blue sky in the background

15 Oct Unlocking the Pros and Cons of Self-Managing Your St. Louis Rental Property: A Comprehensive Guide

St. Louis is a bustling real estate hub with a dynamic rental property market. This brings us to a critical juncture as a property owner: How should you manage your rental property? This article delves into the pros and cons of self-managing your St. Louis rental property.

The Importance of Property Management in St. Louis

Property management in St. Louis isn’t a walk in the park. Many factors are at play, from local housing regulations to unpredictable market trends.

Professional vs Self-Management

Do you hire a property management company or take on the responsibilities yourself? Both choices have their merits and downsides, but let’s focus on the nitty-gritty of self-management.

The Pros and Cons of Self-Managing Your St. Louis Rental Property

Ah, the core of the matter! The decision to self-manage can be as rewarding as it can be daunting.

Lower Costs

One of the most alluring advantages is the cost-saving potential. By eliminating management fees, you directly increase your rental income.

Full Control

You make the rules. You choose the tenants. You decide on the maintenance schedule. In essence, you are the captain of your ship.

Immediate Response

If something goes wrong, you’re just a phone call away. No middlemen, no delays.

Cons: Time-Consuming

Managing a property is a full-time job. It involves paperwork, maintenance calls, and unexpected issues at inconvenient times.

Cons: Legal Complexities

St. Louis has its set of local housing regulations and federal laws. One slip-up and you could be staring at a lawsuit.

Tenant Relations and Communication

At the core of successful property management lies the pivotal role of cultivating effective tenant relations and communication. Nurturing a constructive rapport with your tenants not only heightens their contentment but also plays a significant role in securing longer leases and reducing turnover rates, ultimately delivering a positive impact on your bottom line when you decide to sell your house for cash in St. Louis.

Key Strategies for Effective Communication:

  1. Regular Updates: Keep tenants informed about any changes or repairs that might affect them. This can be done through newsletters, emails, or a dedicated tenant portal.
  2. Quick Response Time: When tenants have complaints or maintenance issues, time is of the essence. Aim to respond to queries within 24 hours to show that you are attentive to their needs.
  3. Transparent Policies: Ensure all rules and regulations are transparent and easily accessible. This reduces misunderstandings and disputes.

Benefits of Good Tenant Relations:

  • Lower Turnover: Satisfied tenants are more likely to renew their leases, reducing the costs of finding new tenants.
  • Positive Reviews: Happy tenants are more likely to leave positive reviews online, which can attract new renters.
  • Easier Management: When you have a good relationship with tenants, they are more likely to comply with community rules, making management tasks less burdensome.

Financial Aspects

Cash Flow Benefits

Another upside is the increase in cash flow. You’re not sharing your profits with a management company, which means more money in your pocket.

Cons: Financial Risk

Being the sole manager comes with added financial liabilities. A bad tenant or an unexpected major repair can take a toll on your finances.

Effective Communication with Tenants

Relationship with Tenants

Direct Communication

Building a rapport with your tenants can be rewarding.

Cons: Conflict Management

Being too close for comfort with your tenants might make it challenging to enforce rules.

Financial Management

Managing the financial aspects of property ownership is crucial for maintaining profitability. Effective financial management entails budgeting, expense tracking, and strategic planning for growth.

Critical Financial Tasks:

  1. Rent Collection: Utilize online payment systems for more streamlined and reliable rent collection.
  2. Expense Tracking: Use accounting software specifically designed for property management to track expenses, from utility bills to maintenance costs.
  3. Financial Forecasting: Conduct periodic reviews of income and fees to identify trends and make future financial projections.

Importance of Financial Management:

  • Profitability: Effective financial management ensures that your property remains profitable by balancing income against expenses.
  • Compliance: Accurate financial records are essential for tax purposes and to comply with local, state, or federal regulations.
  • Investor Relations: Transparent and efficient financial management is attractive to potential investors or partners.

Property Maintenance

Proactive Repairs

You’re in charge of repairs, and this immediate action can save you money in the long run.

Cons: Quality of Repairs

Skimping on repair costs can backfire. Poor-quality repairs may end up costing you more.

Technology’s Role in Self-Management

In today’s world, you don’t have to go it completely alone, thanks to the role of technology in self-management.

Software Solutions

Technology can act as your virtual assistant, from accounting software to tenant portals. These platforms can automate rent collection, service requests, and even some aspects of tenant screening.

Cons: Learning Curve

While technology can be a godsend, there’s a learning curve involved. One needs to be tech-savvy to make the most of these platforms.

Local Real Estate Trends in St. Louis

Keeping up with local real estate trends can give you an edge in self-management. Knowing the market can help you set competitive rental prices and identify desirable neighborhoods.

High ROI Neighborhoods

Areas like Central West End and Clayton offer high ROI due to their appeal to young professionals and students. Self-managing a property in such neighborhoods can be highly lucrative.

Cons: Market Fluctuations

Market trends are like the weather; they can change in the blink of an eye. If you’re current, you may only notice important cues that affect your rental business.

Hiring Property Management Services

Hiring a property management service is often the best solution if you own multiple properties or don’t have the time to manage a property yourself.

What to Look For:

  1. Experience: Check how many years the company has been in business and what kinds of properties they specialize in.
  2. Reviews and References: Look for online reviews or ask for references to gauge the quality of their service.
  3. Scope of Services: Some companies offer comprehensive services, including tenant screening, maintenance, and financial management, while others may specialize in one area.

Benefits of Hiring a Property Management Service:

  • Time Savings: Outsourcing tasks like maintenance and tenant relations saves you time that can be spent on other essential business activities.
  • Professionalism: An experienced property management service can handle problems more efficiently and professionally than a novice.
  • Legal Protection: Property management companies are up-to-date on housing laws and regulations, offering you legal protection.


What are the primary benefits of self-management?

The main perks include cost-saving, decision control, and direct communication with tenants.

How can technology aid in self-management?

Technology offers various tools for automating rent collection, maintenance requests, and more.

What are some financial risks involved?

Potential financial downsides include bad tenants, unexpected repairs, and legal complications.

How can one deal with problematic tenants?

Open communication and a written agreement are vital in managing complex tenant relationships.

Can a property owner juggle between professional work and self-management?

It’s challenging but possible with proper time management and some technological help.

How does the St. Louis real estate market affect self-management?

Local real estate trends can affect rent prices, tenant availability, and ROI. Staying informed is crucial.


By now, you should have a well-rounded view of the pros and cons of self-managing your St. Louis rental property. Like anything worth doing, it comes with its own set of challenges and rewards. Armed with this information, you’re better equipped to make a choice that best suits your lifestyle and financial goals.

Skip to content